Reviewing a Review for Rear Window

I adored Rear Window. I loved the way it was never too much in one genre: sometimes it was thriller and mystery, other times it was romance, and for a few scenes it almost felt like a mockumentary. I read several reviews in preparation for this project and landed on My favourite Hitchcock: Rear Window, written by Killian Fox and published in 2012 by the Guardian. Unlike many reviews I’ve read that are more formulaic, this review intersperses summary with analysis. By including random scenes Fox remembers from his first viewing many years ago, his review reads like a friend explaining their thoughts on a movie you saw a while back.

Fox starts with: “The first time I watched Rear Window, I was 14 or 15 and living in a remote part of Ireland. There was a mile and several hills between us and our nearest neighbours, so the concept of looking out the window and being able to closely survey the lives of an entire community was alien to me, and totally fascinating.” One of the main reasons I became invested in this film was because I live in a city and could understand its portrayal of city life. I know what city heat feels like and can sometimes see what my neighbors are watching on TV, so even though it was set seventy years ago, many aspects still felt relatable. I wonder if the same would be true for viewers from a city watching a film set in a rural area. Nevertheless, this quote shows Hitchcock’s ability to engage viewers from anywhere. He makes the setting central to the storytelling in this film, yet you don’t need to know anything about city life before watching.

Later on in the article, Fox writes, “When I watched Rear Window again at university, I was able to appreciate what the film was saying about the cinema-going experience – of sitting in a dark room and gazing into other people’s private lives.” I like that he brings up that he watched it at university, a place where you are often in a living situation closer to what Jeff has. Although I’ve never lived in a dorm, I can imagine that due to the typical high-density housing, it can be easier to look at your neighbors. I wish Fox wrote more about the similarities he found between the setting of Rear Window and his university life. I understand reviews typically are supposed to be more about the film and less about the writer but this would’ve been a great way to continue the theme started in the first paragraph.

He concludes, “If the film was critical of voyeuristic behaviour, Stewart and his co-conspirators would be proved wrong…this is Hitchcock, connoisseur of the perverse, and the film ended up saying the opposite of what I thought it should.” This is the only line I disagree with. I would not have liked the movie as much if they had been wrong, all the suspense would have been a letdown. In class, we’ve talked about Hitchcock’s “the bomb must never go off” ideology. That seems like it could be applied here, but instead of just the audience knowing about the bomb under the table, the characters know, too. In Rear Window, the characters feel the same type of suspense the viewers do so Hitchcock uses a completely different kind of suspense that only is worth it if what we think is going to happen, happens. I’m not super into thrillers or mysteries, because I’m often pretty gullible when it comes to movies. I tend to believe what the main character believes and I’ve never guessed a plot twist before it occurred unless it’s super cliché. Rear Window is a movie for people like me, I didn’t have to do my own detective work to guess what was going to happen, I just listened to the characters.

Fox ends his article with: “Voyeurism has its rewards; keep a close eye on your neighbours and you might just root out a murderer.” This line seems a bit sarcastic and hyperbolic. You probably won’t solve a murder, but you could tell if a neighbor is sick, or find they have a new lover. Above all, voyeurism (to a respectful extent) creates community. You may not know your neighbor’s name or anything about them, but you know they exist, thus you know you’re not alone.

Fox, Killian. “My favourite Hitchcock: Rear Window | Alfred Hitchcock.” The Guardian, 25 July 2012, https://www.theguardian.com/film/filmblog/2012/jul/25/my-favourite-hitchcock-rear-window.